Our team is committed to providing exceptional service. With expertise in various fields of education and training, we bring a well-rounded perspective to meet your insurance needs. As residents of the area and surrounding communities, we understand the importance of being physically present and accessible to our clients. We’re here for you, offering personalized support, and together we’re building strong, lasting relationships that help everyone thrive!

  • :
  • English
a person with long hair

Erin Hibbard

Sales Specialist - All Lines
Erin is fully licensed in all lines of insurance and is ready to assist with your Auto, Property, Boat, Specialty Vehicle, Umbrella, Life, and Business insurance needs. With a decade of experience at American Family and in the insurance industry, she brings a wealth of expertise to every client interaction. Outside of work, Erin enjoys spending quality time with her family, friends, and her pets!

Evan McGinnis

Customer Service Representative
Evan is fully licensed in all lines of insurance and is here to assist you with servicing your policies. Whether you're visiting the office or calling in, he's the first friendly face you'll encounter, always ready to help. A proud graduate of UW Milwaukee, Evan also offers valuable expertise in technology solutions, IT consulting, and marketing, which he leverages to enhance your experience.

Jonetta Haibel

Office Manager
Jonetta is a licensed professional in all lines of insurance with over two decades of experience at Am Fam and in the industry. She's available to schedule a Personal Insurance Review, ensuring that your coverage is tailored to meet your specific needs. With her extensive knowledge and efficiency, Jonetta excels at servicing, reviewing, and updating coverages to keep your policy in top shape!